
By Kylie Klein-Nixon
Digital Journalist | Kaipūrongo Matihiko
It’s hard to imagine an advent calendar being controversial, but Kim Kardashian’s underwear brand Skims has managed it this year with the Accessories Advent Calendar 2026.

Skims launched its Accessories Advent Calendar in October as part of a holiday collection. Costing US$148 (NZ$270), it promised 12 days of small surprises.
According to the proliferation of unboxing videos that popped up shortly afterwards, however, it seems the real surprise is the perceived cheapness of the contents. Clips on TikTok and Instagram showed an assortment of bobby pins, hair ties, key chains and headbands that looked like bra straps.
“I can’t believe I’ve had a Skims Advent Calendar in the bottom of my purse for months, what a surprise,” a Threads user wrote.
One TikToker likened the “haul” to the detritus found under sofa cushions.
Another wrote she hoped “this is a prank and the last one is a $150 gift card for all my money back.”
One clip amassed tens of millions of views, prompting widespread criticism online and media coverage of the backlash.
Given the flood of outraged unboxing videos that followed, the controversy may actually have helped sales by turning the calendar into a viral curiosity.

Get 50% off our Sale Season Pass
We’ll help you dodge the duds and find the deals worth your hard-earned cash.
It’s not just Skims
Poor old Kim wasn’t the only celebrity whose advent calendar came in for a drubbing this year.
Meghan Markle’s lifestyle brand, As Ever, also released an advent calendar in October, a collaboration with Los Angeles chocolatier Compartés.
At NZ$269 for 24 chocolates, the British press was as calm and rational as ever, with the Express gleefully trumpeting that the Duchess of Sussex had been “brutally savaged” online after releasing a “ridiculous” £112 advent calendar.
The paper pulled a few choice quotes from social media, including one that claimed the Royal Collection shop at Buckingham Palace offers a similar chocolate calendar for £12, implying the difference in price was a black mark on the duchess’s character.
You can see where both celebrity-backed calendars landed in our rankings below.
Value vs surprise
Retailers of luxury advent calendars have learned to balance consumers’ expectations of transparency around value, particularly at what can be exorbitant prices, with the basic premise of an advent calendar: blind-box style surprise and delight.
They will sometimes include a “to the value of” price in the listing, so you can see if you are really getting a good deal. Some also hide detailed lists of the contents behind drop-down boxes with spoiler warnings, so you don’t have to see what you’re getting if you don’t want to.
How we scored them
We compared 16 luxury advent calendars available to New Zealand shoppers this silly season, scoring each out of 100 for value for money (40%), contents (30%), variety (15%) and presentation (15%).
Where manufacturers did not publish a contents value, we assumed the contents were worth at least the purchase price. As a result, calendars that didn’t disclose a contents value could not score highly on value for money.
We’ve indicated where that was the case each time.
Because advent calendars contain everything from jewellery to whisky samples and beauty products, we assessed contents based on the quantity and completeness of gifts rather than attempting to compare quality across different categories.
Finally, while some of these items need to be ordered from overseas, we’ve kept all the prices in NZD.
Our ranking, from best to worst
Three of the most expensive advent calendars of all time
Was this page helpful?

How to save more than $1,000 on TV streaming services

Best stick vacuum cleaners of 2026

4 things to avoid buying at Kmart
