Join ConsumerLoginDonate
  • Consumer NZ
  • About us
  • Consumer rights and advice
  • Subscribe to our newsletters
  • Terms and conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Community guidelines
  • Contact us
  • Membership
  • Join
  • Consumer magazine
  • Consumer Advice Line
  • Top tests and reviews
  • Other sites
  • Powerswitch
  • Consumer Foundation
  • Campaigns
  • End high power prices now
  • Fair repayment for retirement village residents
  • For businesses
  • Work with us

Follow us

© Copyright Consumer NZ. All rights reserved.
<Deals & savings
  1. Home/
  2. Shopping/
  3. Deals & savings/
  4. Are these 5 retailers playing by the sales rules?

Are these 5 retailers playing by the sales rules?

20 November 2026
Rebecca  2

By Rebecca Styles

Research Lead | Hautū Rangahau

We investigate how special the “deals” at Briscoes, Farmers, Harvey Norman, JB Hi-Fi and Noel Leeming really are.

Consumer NZ tracked 13 products at Briscoes, Farmers, Harvey Norman, JB Hi-Fi and Noel Leeming over 12 weeks to see whether the big retailers were playing by the rules set out in the Fair Trading Act.

On this page

  • Big box retailers ranked best to worst 
  • Where could you get the cheapest price? 

We evaluated the retailers against these rules:

  • A sale must give shoppers a genuine opportunity to buy a product at a discounted price for a short period.

  • If a business continually sells a product at a discounted price, that’s the usual selling price – not a special.

  • When a retailer compares a sale price with a previous price (for example, “was $100, now $50”), the “was” price must be the genuine price the product sold for over a reasonable period.

  • Retailers shouldn’t inflate a product’s normal price, knowing it won’t sell at that price, just to discount it later to get sales.

  • Clearance sales create a sense of urgency and should only be used for clearing stock. You shouldn’t see clearance stock back on the shelves at full price after the sale ends.

We found that promotional language around sales was often confusing and, at some retailers, misleading. This risks breaching the Fair Trading Act. We’ll pass our findings on to the Commerce Commission.

The take-home message? Ignore the sale pitch and track prices to make sure you’re getting the best deal.

Get 50% off our Sale Season Pass

We’ll help you dodge the duds and find the deals worth your hard-earned cash.

Learn more

Big box retailers ranked best to worst

We ranked the “Big 5” big box retailers on how reliable their sales are – looking at price and promotional language to assess whether shoppers are getting a genuine special.

1. Briscoes

Briscoes came out on top because its sale prices were clearly cheaper than its usual prices. It was also easier to tell what the usual price was, and Briscoes used less promotional language for its sales.

The key feature of Briscoes pricing was that discounted prices kept coming back, rather than being exceptional, one-off bargains.

The retailer rotates between high and low pricing. Eleven of the products we tracked reached 50% off their highest price. The Panasonic microwave we tracked cracked 60% off.

The prices repeatedly return to full price between promotions. Given the regularity of the sales, you’d be daft to pay full price for anything at Briscoes.

One note of warning: just because something is on special at Briscoes doesn’t mean it’s the cheapest price available. The lowest price for the Ninja Air fryer at Briscoes was $125 while Noel Leeming had it for $97.

2. Farmers

Farmers just pipped JB Hi-Fi for second place because its promotional language indicated the cheapest price slightly more often than its competitor.

Like JB Hi-Fi, Farmers generally follows a regular pattern of a product being on sale for a few weeks before it returns to full price.

Its “great price” labelling let it down because it didn’t reliably indicate a low price.

The Fisher and Paykel Series 5 top loader carried the “great price” label throughout the 12 weeks we tracked, yet its actual price jumped around. The cheapest price was $1,248 and the highest $1,669, with a gift card included at the higher price.

The Samsung heat-pump dryer was also a “great price” at $1,399, then again the following week at $1,989.

3. JB Hi-Fi

We ranked JB Hi-Fi third because its promotional sales language didn’t necessarily mean shoppers were getting the cheapest deal.

More than half of the prices we recorded had some kind of promotional label. “Red hot deal” and “on sale” were the most common.

The Breville Barista Express was “on sale” for $600, then a “red hot deal” the following week at $698. We also saw it labelled a “red hot deal” at $848. Neither “red hot deal” price was as low as the $600 sale price. The highest price we recorded was $999.

As with Briscoes, regular discounting was a strong feature of JB Hi-Fi’s pricing, but promotional labels didn’t reliably signal the lowest price.

Products frequently dropped in price for one or more weeks, then returned to a higher price before dropping again a few weeks later.

4. Harvey Norman

Last year, we took Harvey Norman to task over price labels on almost every product making it look like they were constantly discounted. This year, we’re pleased to see it has dropped most of the labels. Yet we still rank it near the bottom of the pack because we think confusion around what counts as a “deal” remains.

Harvey Norman continued to use some promotional labels, as well as red text, to suggest a deal. Neither necessarily meant a lower price. It was also hard to tell what the usual price was.

The Breville toaster we tracked was labelled a “birthday deal” at $129, but that wasn’t the best price we saw for the product – it was cheaper the following week at $115.

The toaster’s price was also displayed in red text throughout our tracking, yet fluctuated between $112 and $135. It was hard to tell what the full price of the toaster was.

5. Noel Leeming

We placed Noel Leeming at the bottom of the pack because of its frequent use of sales promotional language.

Its promotional labels didn’t reliably tell us which prices were lowest. Over 12 weeks, we saw labels such as “Price smash”, “epic deal” and “mega deal” yet it was hard to tell which suggested the biggest bargain.

The Ninja Air Fryer cost $129 in a “massive sellout”, but we saw it for less under a different label: a “price smash” at $97, the lowest price we found.

In fact, the air fryer had a promo label for the 11 weeks it was available. It was either a “real deal”, a “massive sellout” or an “epic deal”, or had free delivery.

At $869, the Breville Barista Express was labelled a “mega deal” yet this was the highest price we recorded for it at Noel Leeming. Mega, massive or epic? The labels sent us to the dictionary, but the prices told the clearer story: the mega deal was meagre.

We think these labels suggest a promotional campaign rather than any genuine link to price savings. As such, we think they risk misleading customers.

Where could you get the cheapest price?

Rather than relying on promotional claims, we recommend tracking prices for a few weeks to make sure you’re getting the best deal. There are savings to be had.

Here are some products from our tracking where we found big differences in price.

About our data

We tracked 13 products at each of the five retailers over 12 weeks, recording prices every Friday. While some products were the same across retailer, we did tweak the product selection to reflect what each retailer sold.

Find the real deals

This year, we’re tracking the sales to help Consumer members spot the bona fide bargains, based on both price and performance.

Learn more

Read more:ShoppingShopping the salesOnline shoppingEveryday shoppingBlack FridayDeals & savings

Comments

Get access to comment
Join Consumer
Log in
Loading comments...

Was this page helpful?

Person using stick vacuum cleaner on hard floor.

Best stick vacuum cleaners of 2026

Best deals of the week

4 things to avoid buying at Kmart

Best robot vacuum cleaners in 2026